How do you know that training is effective?

Organisations often respond to new legislation and regulations through the delivery of training to control the risk of “the thing” happening and prevent non-compliance. But if training is one of your controls - how do you know it’s effective, and how do you prove it?

As an ex-teacher I believe firmly in the power of education. I draft and deliver professional development as well as co-designing culture through practical workshop experiences. But this week, two posts on LinkedIn made me question the benefits realised from workplace training and whether we know how to get the most benefit out of it.

Ayoka Solomon, LCSW made the point that not every problem is a leadership problem, and that we often offer training before we've clearly defined what we're trying to solve. Jason van Schie responded to a public notice the Department of Defence published following the death of a worker and questioned what it takes for an organisation to show that it's controls, training included, are working.

Read together they ask the same question: when training is the right answer, what makes it effective and how do we prove it? The published notice is a sobering reminder of this question's importance.

In proceedings brought by Comcare, the department was penalised over the death of a worker who had been through a performance management process. From my understanding, Defence admitted that it hadn't trained supervisors to understand that managing underperformance through a work plan may itself be a psychosocial hazard, to identify the risks for workers going through that process and to minimise those risks, including knowing when to pause the process.

Jason asked some good questions:

Do your managers know performance management is a hazard, and not just an HR procedure?

Can they spot a worker who isn’t coping?

Do they know when to stop, pause or escalate?

Does it appear on your risk register with controls you can show are working?

The big gap

Plenty of employers - public and private sector - are investing in training on psychosocial safety and good management practice recognising the outsize impact managers have on worker experience. But I regularly see the same complaint - it didn't realise what we wanted it to - or - we didn't realise the gap in their knowledge. This gap, in my opinion, opens up in two places: before training begins and when they walk out the door.

Rarely does a workplace explain prior to training what participants are expected to do with the experience, and what they're required to impact when they return to the workplace. It seems silly to have to do this, but it's helpful to engage the participant as an important and active participant in the organisational improvement process, set the expectation that action will result from application of learnings, and prime the brain before they session even starts. This is about them considering not just what they want to get from it as an individual learner, but what their organisation needs them doing with it.

We similarly ignore post-training embedding of learnings. Participants return to a few hundred emails that piled up in their absence. The workbook goes on a shelf, it's key ideas not translated into their team or organisational context. And if you're lucky, there's a conversation that goes something like: "How did it go?" "Yeah, good."

I had a conversation with a client recently who told me their management team had been on multiple management courses to support improvement in people leadership but none of it seemed to make any difference. Interestingly, the management team could discuss any of the theories covered and knew all the 'progressive thinking' lines that we love to trot out in these courses. "Their door was always open". What may have helped in this case - and indeed many others - is a clear discussion around the expectations of attending, including an understanding of, and plan for, how they will embed those learnings in the workplace once they return.

Knowing what needs to be done is one thing - knowing how to make it happen is a totally different thing.

One golden opportunity to test effectiveness of learning is the follow-up from leaders once participants return to the office. It's a chance to revisit key learnings, as well as test how deep the learning went, and if there is an understanding about how to practically implement it.

Sending people to training for risks like psychosocial safety and registering their attendance isn't enough anymore. If training is one of your controls - you need evidence that it's actually effective.

Testing learnings

We've known for a long time that information learned once rarely sticks. Research suggests that recalling information over time helps make it last. It also helps to make predictions about how they information could be applied, and to look at where current practice might be amended for a better outcome. In other words, the learning needs to be recalled, applied, and reflected upon multiple times.

Social application is even better. Research on the transfer of training recognises the importance of the work environment, especially support from a supervisor, as a strong influence on whether new skills are used on job. In my experience, an informal coaching conversation with a leader in the days following a course makes a remarkable difference. Talking about it over time - about how the implementation of ideas is faring and the steps they're taking - is even better. The conversation doesn't need to be elaborate. A leader might ask:

What stood out for you?

What did it confirm about your own practice?

What would you like to try differently?

How might you implement it? What steps do you think you might take, and what comes first?

How will you know if it's working?

If it is working, what will it look like, sound like and feel like for you and the team?

And later on - What's working? What's not? How might it be more effective? How is it showing up in our data? And the biggest one - what evidence are you relying on when making these judgements?

In my experience, questions like these get far more out of a training investment. They turn a day off-site into changes in how people lead and give your 1:1s something concrete to work with.

Back to the beginning

Ayoka was right. Training shouldn't be a reflex response to a problem nobody has properly defined. Sometimes training is exactly the right answer - but only if steps are taken to embed it into daily leadership life.

Individual learning experiences on their own don't create a learning culture. How we secure the learning into consistent daily practice is what determines whether the benefit of training is realised, and most of that work happens before and after the training. So next time someone in your team comes back from a course, put 30 minutes in the diary to ask them what stood out, and a reminder for your 1:1s to check in the weeks following. It may just be the most valuable part of the whole program.

Reach out if you’re interested in building coaching skills in your managers.

Next
Next

When rising EAP use is a good thing